Page of

Supporting Competing Narratives

Supporting Competing Narratives

A Membership Categorization Analysis of Identity Work in Police-Detainee Talk

Chapter:
(p.156) Chapter Eight Supporting Competing Narratives
Source:
The Discourse of Police Interviews
Author(s):
David YoongAyeshah Syed
Publisher:
University of Chicago Press
DOI:10.7208/chicago/9780226647821.003.0008

This chapter examines identity-related categories that emerge in a post-sting operation interview between an undercover officer (and his colleague) and a high-profile detainee, who had allegedly solicited sexual activity in a public bathroom. Using the Membership Categorization Analysis approach, we show how officer and detainee use identity categories and predicates to perform actions, including providing accounts, making accusations and denials, and eliciting a confession. Drawing on morally-implicative, physical and institutional categorical resources, the speakers support their own version of events and reject the conflicting version preferred by the other.

Keywords:   Membership Categorization Analysis, identity, morally-implicative categories, undercover sting, police interview

Sign In

Copyright © 2021. All rights reserved.
Privacy Policy and Legal Notice