Optional LawThe Structure of Legal Entitlements

Optional LawThe Structure of Legal Entitlements

Ian Ayres

Print publication date: 2013

ISBN: 9780226033464

Publisher: University of Chicago Press

Abstract

Spurred by the advances in option theory that have been remaking financial and economic scholarship over the past thirty years, a revolution is taking shape in the way legal scholars conceptualize property and the way it is protected by the law. This book explores how option theory is overthrowing many accepted wisdoms and producing tangible new tools for courts in deciding cases. It identifies flaws in the current system and shows how option theory can radically expand and improve the ways that lawmakers structure legal entitlements. It shows that an option-based system gives parties the option to purchase—or the option to sell—the relevant legal entitlement. Choosing to exercise a legal option forces decisionmakers to reveal information about their own valuation of the entitlement. And, as with auctions, entitlements in option-based law naturally flow to those who value them the most. Seeing legal entitlements through this lens suggests a variety of new entitlement structures from which lawmakers might choose. The book provides a theory for determining which structure is likely to be most effective in harnessing parties' private information. It proposes a practical approach to the foundational question of how to allocate and protect legal rights.